Hired a UX designer who turned out to just UI focused.. how to aim for someone with problem-solving skills?
Selecting the Right UX Professional: Moving Beyond UI Focus to Problem-Solving Expertise
Hiring the ideal UX designer is a critical step in ensuring the success of user-centered projects. Recently, however, a scenario underscored the importance of evaluating candidates not just for their design skills but for their problem-solving capabilities and strategic thinking. Here’s an in-depth look at this challenge and guidance on how to better identify the right candidate for your needs.
A Cautionary Tale: When Design Focus Overshadows User Experience
In a recent experience, a company hired a UX designer based on a promising interview performance. The candidate showcased a refined portfolio, emphasized the significance of user research and usability testing, and appeared knowledgeable. However, after 12 weeks on the job, it became evident that the candidate’s work was narrowly focused on aesthetics—primarily making things look visually appealing—rather than addressing core user problems.
The issues surfaced during client meetings, where the designer’s responses were limited to superficial adjustments, such as color changes or layout tweaks. When questioned about design decisions, the responses centered on visual aspects rather than the underlying user needs or data-driven insights. Moreover, there was little evidence of research, testing, or engagement with user flows, which are essential components of effective UX work.
Understanding the Gap: From UI to UX Problem-Solving
This experience highlights a common pitfall in the hiring process: conflating UI design skills with comprehensive UX expertise. While proficiency with tools like Figma and a keen eye for aesthetics are valuable, successful UX design also requires:
- Analytical thinking and problem-solving skills
- A deep understanding of user needs and behaviors
- Experience with research methodologies, testing, and data analysis
- Ability to translate insights into functional, user-centered solutions
- Effective communication and collaboration with stakeholders and clients
Strategies for Hiring the Right UX Talent
To avoid similar issues in future hires, consider refining your interview and evaluation practices. Here are some recommendations:
- Behavioral and Situational Interview Questions
- Ask candidates to describe specific instances where they identified a user problem and how they approached solving it.
-
Example: “Can you tell me about a time when user research led you to change your initial design concept? How did you handle it?”
-
Assess Problem-Solving and Critical Thinking
- Present real or hypothetical project scenarios related to your dashboard project.
-
Request that candidates walk through their process for understanding the problem, gathering insights, and arriving at solutions.
-
Evaluate Research and Testing Knowledge
- Inquire about their experience with usability tests, user interviews, surveys, or analytics.
-
Ask for examples of how data influenced their design decisions.
-
Portfolio Review Focused on Problem-Solving
- Analyze their past work for evidence of user research, challenges faced, and how those were addressed.
-
Look beyond visual design and assess the reasoning behind design choices.
-
Practical Exercises or Assignments
- Provide a brief project brief and ask candidates to develop a problem-focused UX solution, explaining their approach and reasoning.
-
This can reveal their ability to think critically and solve problems effectively.
-
Collaborative and Communication Skills
- Observe how candidates articulate their thought process and work with stakeholders, which is vital for implementing user-centered solutions.
Moving Forward
Given your current situation, it may be necessary to revisit your hiring criteria and process to better align with the essential skills your project demands. While you might need to consider hiring another professional, these practices can help ensure that future candidates are evaluated more holistically—balancing aesthetic capabilities with strategic problem-solving and research expertise.
Investing time in refining your interview questions and assessment methods will ultimately lead to a more competent team capable of delivering designs that truly solve user problems, adding greater value to your projects and clients.
Conclusion
Effective UX design extends beyond visually appealing interfaces—it’s fundamentally about understanding user challenges and crafting solutions rooted in research and data. By emphasizing problem-solving skills and critical thinking during your hiring process, you can select professionals who not only design beautiful interfaces but also deliver meaningful, user-centered experiences.